£1.4million in Interim Payments for Medical Negligence Claim


David Thomas, a Medical Negligence Solicitor and Partner at Simpson Millar, took on the case and explains how the claim has progressed, and how it has rewritten the record books on the amount of compensation awarded for interim payments in a medical negligence claim.

£1.4million Interim Payments of Compensation

The cumulative sum of interim payments so far has reached £1.4million, a figure that has seen Simpson Millar break records for awards of this nature. This is due largely to a recent change in the way compensation is calculated for life changing injury claims.

Medical Negligence Case Details

A child born with a severe brain injury, resulting in a lifelong requirement for full-time care, made a claim for medical negligence against the hospital trust responsible for their condition.

Failure in Duty of Care

The claimant in this case study – referred to from this point forward as Child A – was born with a severe case of hypoxia, a condition that deprives the supply of oxygen to body tissue. It's manageable if detected and treated in time, but delays can lead to a brain injury with catastrophic consequences for the victim.

As a result of the hypoxia, Child A was left with a range of conditions requiring round-the-clock support. The extent of these conditions meant they were also classed as a Protected Party, lacking the mental capacity to make informed decisions for themselves due to the severity of the brain injury they had sustained.

The claim alleged that the obstetric staff responsible for Child A's wellbeing prior to, during and after childbirth, failed in their duty of care by not identifying or responding to the hypoxia effectively. The hospital trust admitted full liability for the birth injuries and Judgment was entered with damages to be assessed by the High Court.

Unsuitable Environment

As the value of the compensation award would take time to be determined, the hospital trust agreed to make a voluntary interim payment in order to meet Child A's immediate needs. A sum of £100,000 was paid, which was followed up later the same year, on order of the High Court, by a further payment of £800,000 compensation.

During this time it became apparent that Child A's home was not a suitable environment for dealing with the considerable range of physical and mental issues affecting them. The day-to-day care required to ensure the optimum quality of life possible meant equipment was needed, such as hoists, that the current home could not sustain. As Child A grew, the need for accommodation that met their reasonable requirements became more pressing. A further interim payment from the hospital trust was therefore sought by the family and Simpson Millar, in order to secure a bungalow that could fit this purpose.

Improved Quality of Life

The judgement of JR v Sheffield Teaching Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust (2017) meant it was now necessary to persuade a Court that there was a genuine need for extra funds, with the amount of compensation being sought not exceeding a reasonable proportion of the final damages likely to be awarded. There was also a need to demonstrate that any additional and substantial interim payment would not affect the Judge's discretion when it came to making a Periodical Payment Order (PPO), which are paid in annual instalments for life, as opposed to a single lump sum.

The hospital trust, initially unwilling to make another interim payment, eventually accepted that Child A's accommodation was not satisfactory for their reasonable needs and a large 4 or 5 bedroom bungalow was necessary for a more appropriate care regime to be implemented.

A further interim payment of £500,000 was awarded by the High Court Judge overseeing the case, which allowed the family of Child A to buy a bungalow with enough room to provide living quarters for a professional carer, as well as fit all the necessary equipment required to assist with the child's day-to-day needs. This move to a new home has marked a significant improvement in Child A's quality of life.

Commenting on the case, Medical Negligence Solicitor David Thomas said, "This case highlights how a simple medical error – in this instance, the failure to detect or respond to the hypoxia – can have absolutely devastating consequences for a new born baby’s future. And it isn't just the victim of the negligence who is affected, but the families and loved ones too."

If you believe that you or a loved one has suffered from clinical or medical negligence, get in touch for a free consultation to see how we can help you.

For free legal advice call our Medical Negligence Solicitors

We're happy to help

Monday to Friday 8:30am-7:00pm

0808 239 6043

0808 239 6043

We're happy to call you

Simply click below to arrange a call

Request a Call Back

Request a Callback

This data will only be used by Simpson Millar in accordance with our Privacy Policy for processing your query and for no other purpose