High Court Ruling - Wife Can Decide on Contact with Husband Only

25th March 2020

A judgment handed down at the Court of Protection sitting in the High Court today has ruled that a woman with a relatively rare form of dementia lacks the capacity to make certain decisions for herself, including making decisions about her contact with others except her husband, to whom she has been married for over 25 years.

The ruling, which was handed down this morning, follows a one day hearing that took place in March 2020 during which the Court heard that a married woman with complex health and social care needs – known only as SF – had allegedly been sexually exploited by a man who visited her home while her husband was at work.

The case was brought by of an unnamed Local Authority in Yorkshire which called on the Court to make decisions as to whether the woman had the mental capacity to consent to sexual relations.

Experts involved in the hearing said that while her deteriorating condition means her ability to understand and appraise her own emotions and the non-verbal cues of persons she does not know, is impaired, she still has a level of knowledge, appreciation and understanding of her husband which she uses to make decisions about her relationship with him.

In a report produced by Dr Rebecca O’Donovan, a Consultant Forensic Psychiatrist, who was instructed by both the Local Authority and Official Solicitor, it was revealed that the woman showed signs of going along with things regardless of whether she was comfortable or happy to do so, but as she has historically been a passive person, it was difficult to determine whether her presentation was down to her personality or due to her dementia.

However, while the report found that the woman struggled to make decisions regarding her contact with others, her husband was a different matter as, using knowledge from her past, she could read his body language and make informed decisions about her relationship with him, which she could not do with people she had just met or did not know so well.

Speaking of today’s judgment Caroline Hurst from law firm Simpson Millar, who was instructed by the Official Solicitor to represent SF throughout the case said, “This is an important ruling which unusually differentiates the ability of a person who does not have the capacity to make informed decisions about their contact with someone who they have a history with, from those they do not.

“While SF’s condition will need to be carefully monitored in order to ensure that the authority is acting in her best interests moving forward, for now, the judgment recognises that she can make an informed choice with regards her relationship with her husband, even if she is not able to do so with others.

“This by no means sets a precedent for other individuals in similar circumstances. What it does is provide clarity in so far as each case must be considered with their own set of unique circumstances in mind.”

The case, which was bought by the Local Council, sought clarity on the protection that she required given her complex health and social care needs – including a diagnosis of frontal lobe dementia – amidst concerns that she may have  been subjected to alleged sexual exploitation by a man who visited her home while her husband was at work.

As part of the judgment Mr Justice Cobb said that it was in her best interest to continue living with her husband without restriction, but that she should continue to receive assisted care during the day to protect her from further potential exploitation.

Due to the deterioration of condition linked to her frontal lobe dementia it has been determined that a further review of the woman’s capacity will be necessary, and a further assessment and review hearing will follow.

For free legal advice, call our Public Law Solicitors

We're happy to help

Monday to Friday 8:30am-7:00pm

08002 605 010

08002 605 010

We're happy to call you

Simply click below to arrange a call

Request a call back

Request a Callback

This data will only be used by Simpson Millar in accordance with our Privacy Policy for processing your query and for no other purpose

Simpson Millar is a national law firm with over 500 staff and offices in Bristol, Cardiff, Lancaster, Leeds, Liverpool, London - Euston, London - Fleet Street, London - Teddington, Manchester and Southport.