Inquest Finds Death of Sheffield man at Bail Hostel Could Have Been Prevented With More Support
The family of a young man who died while staying at Norfolk Park Probation Hostel in Sheffield have spoken of their grief after an inquest found that if he had received more support his death could have been prevented.
Jamie Lee Bennett, 33, passed away on 2 May 2020, just one day after being released from prison.
A ‘devoted and thoughtful soul’, who was working hard to maintain abstinence from substance misuse, his family say he had been determined to turn his life around following what had been a difficult time.
However, at the inquest which concluded on 29 April 2022, Assistant Coroner Tanyka Rawden heard evidence of multiple failings in the care that Jamie received both whilst in prison and in the short time that he was at the hostel where he was required to reside under the terms of his licence.
She concluded that the prison healthcare service did not formally consider retoxification or fully follow its policy in relation to releasing prisoners with Naloxone and, crucially, she found that that there was a failure to provide information about Jamie, and that Jamie had reduced support at the hostel in the key 48 hours after his release from prison.
She concluded that if that additional support had been put in place during that period, he might not have taken drugs or died.
She also found that there was a lack of training of staff including first aid training and how to conduct crucial welfare checks on residents and that there was a gap in staff’s knowledge in making an emergency response.
The family were supported following Jamie’s death by the charity INQUEST, which helps families following state related deaths.
The current system in place to support vulnerable prisoners in the early days of their release is not fit for its purpose and leads to many deaths every year. An urgent change is needed in relation to the services provided on the ground by all the agencies in concern - , Senior Caseworker, INQUEST
Following the inquest, Assistant Coroner Tanyka Rawden said she intended to make two Prevention of Future Death reports to the Practice Plus Group (responsible for prison healthcare) and the Ministry of Justice, voicing her various concerns about the identified failings that still have not been addressed.
Speaking following the hearing the family’s lawyer, Public Law expert Aimee Brackenfield from Simpson Millar who represented them during the hearing, said it was ‘imperative’ that lessons were learnt to prevent further tragedy.
Laura Bennett, Jamie’s sister, said: “Jamie was a devoted and thoughtful soul who will be dearly missed. He was a loving son, father, brother, nephew, cousin and friend.
“While this Inquest has given us some answers to the questions we have had for so long, it is extremely upsetting to hear that more could, and should, have been done to help him with his recovery. Especially at a time of transition when he really needed that support.
“I hope that no one has to go through what my family has been through, and I hope that all of the findings that have come to light mean action is taken so that no one has to suffer as we have in the future.”
Aimee Brackfield from Simpson Millar added: “Today’s narrative verdict shines a light on a number of fundamental failings in the care that Jamie received. The bail hostel was a place where he should have felt safe and looked after.
“The Coroner heard evidence that information about Jamie’s substance misuse and his low tolerance to drugs as a result of his abstinence was not passed on to the bail hostel before Jamie’s release.
“Sadly, Jamie left prison without Naloxone, a potentially life-saving treatment for drug overdose, and the reasons for this were not recorded.
“The Coroner also identified that there was no plan in relation to supporting Jamie, particularly in relation to his substance misuse, when he was released to the bail hostel."
Throughout the hearing the Coroner heard evidence from a number of witnesses, who confirmed that on 2 May 2020 Jamie was seen by a member of staff at 7am, but that member of staff did not rouse Jamie and could not confirm whether or not he was breathing.
That morning the family became concerned having not heard from Jamie and asked another resident to check on him. That resident raised concerns with staff, who had missed the mandatory 12 noon welfare checks. Staff checked on Jamie as a result of the concerns raised by the family, at 1:35pm and sadly he was found unresponsive and soon after pronounced dead.
The Coroner heard that many staff did not have first aid training, they did not carry radios or first aid kits with them when checking on residents, and they were not aware of their responsibilities in relation to carrying out mandatory checks and how those checks should be carried out.
Aimee Brackfield added: “The family are truly devastated to learn that Jamie’s death could have been prevented, and it is now imperative that the coroner’s findings are acted upon, and changes made, so that others do not need to suffer in the same way that they have moving forward.
“They would like to thank the Coroner for her time, and for her efforts to make two Prevention of Future Death reports to the Practice Plus Group (responsible for prison healthcare) and the Ministry of Justice.”
Speaking following the hearing the family said they were keen to raise awareness about substance misuse and how individuals can get help.
Selen Cavcav, Senior Caseworker, INQUEST, added: “The failures identified in this inquest both by the prison and probation service are truly disturbing. Jamie’s death was not only entirely preventable but also predictable.
“The current system in place to support vulnerable prisoners in the early days of their release is not fit for its purpose and leads to many deaths every year. An urgent change is needed in relation to the services provided on the ground by all the agencies in concern”.
For free legal advice call our Public Law and Human Rights Solicitors
We're happy to help
Monday to Friday 8:30am-7:00pm
0808 239 1344
We're happy to call you
Simply click below to arrange a call